In recent decades, a monumental error has shaped player development in Major League Baseball. Players have even been signed professionally without knowing the basic rules—or without knowing how to play baseball well at all. Don’t believe it? Arrive early at a stadium and you will see professional athletes who cannot field routine ground balls or hit to the opposite field.
This error, rooted in the late 1980s and 1990s, produced an excessive focus on physical tools while relegating talent, instincts, and intelligence to a secondary role. As dramatic as it sounds, this is the reality.
MLB has fallen into the trap of valuing raw physical ability—especially arm strength and pitch velocity—while neglecting the foundational pillars of athletic performance: talent and game intelligence, often referred to as sports IQ.
In sports, IQ is not a measure of general cognitive ability. It refers specifically to tactical intelligence: the capacity to read the game, anticipate plays, make rapid decisions, and apply strategies that change outcomes. Yet MLB has pushed these qualities aside in favor of radar-gun readings and body metrics.
This mentality has fueled a crisis that now manifests in alarming injury trends.
A Crisis Rooted in the 1990s
Studies over the past decade show up to a 30% increase in ulnar collateral ligament reconstruction surgeries—Tommy John procedures required to repair elbow ligament tears. This surge traces back to the chaotic 1990s, marked by the steroid era, the 1994 strike, and the misguided belief that throwing harder was automatically better.
That mindset shaped youth development for decades, and the consequences are visible today.
During that period, MLB became obsessed with physical spectacle—home runs, velocity, power—while ignoring talent, baseball IQ, and the art of playing the game. That mentality persists today and is evident in modern scouting and development.
Other Leagues Learned the Lesson. MLB Didn’t.
Unlike MLB, other leagues value intelligence and talent alongside athleticism.
NBA scouts don’t recruit simply based on vertical leap or wingspan. They evaluate ball-handling, playmaking, decision-making, court vision, and spatial understanding.
Soccer scouts don’t sign a player solely because they shoot hard. They evaluate technical skill, tactical intelligence, off-ball movement, and decision-making. Athleticism is required, but never confused with talent.
MLB, however, often confuses raw physical tools with baseball ability.
It is time for MLB to reassess its approach: to restore the balance between physical attributes, talent, and game intelligence. Only then can baseball return to the diverse and creative game it once was.
Without Talent and Intelligence, There Is No Success
Former MLB pitcher Pedro Martínez has publicly warned about this problem:
“It’s disheartening to see how fundamental aspects such as talent and intelligence are overlooked. The obsession with physical qualities has led to a loss of diversity in the game.”
Draft data confirms a strong bias toward prospects with extreme physical metrics—pitchers throwing 95+ mph, players with outsized wingspans—while their real-world decision-making ability is barely considered.
The developmental shortcomings are so severe that many young pitchers are converted from position players purely because of arm strength. Only years later do they begin to learn pitch sequencing, command, or how to read hitters. This is the opposite of professional development.
Meanwhile, the NBA and world football (soccer) continue evolving because they value complete athletes: physically gifted and intelligent.
NBA scout Mike Zarren put it clearly:
“We look for athletes who are not only impressive physically but who understand the game and make smart decisions.”
And Pep Guardiola, one of football’s greatest tacticians, reinforces the point:
“The most successful players combine technical excellence with a deep understanding of the game. That is what makes the difference.”
MLB must learn the same lesson.
If the league wants to maintain a high level of competition—something many experts believe has declined—it must radically reform its player development philosophy. Talent and intelligence are not optional traits; they are foundational.
The long-term health, performance, and evolution of baseball depend on restoring what the sport itself invented: a balance between skills, intelligence, and athleticism.
English 
Spanish 